MK Party Faces Growing Criticism Amid Leadership Crisis

(The Post News)- The uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) Party, which once introduced itself as a revolutionary out of the ordinary ruling party different from the African National Congress (ANC), is now under increasing scrutiny for what political analysts describe as having extensive internal dysfunction, questionable leadership practices and nepotism. Former MK national organiser McDonald Mathabe has become known as one of the party’s most outspoken critics, warning that the MK Party is drifting into an imperilment state of failing to uphold the core values and principles on which MK was founded.

In an interview with Newsroom Afrika, Mathabe painted a disheartening picture of a party in disorder. He reiterated that instead of becoming a disciples and people-oriented movement, MK has tumbled into chaos, factionalism, and personal ambition. “ The truth is, MK is worse than the ANC right now,” he said. There is no solid strategic direction. There is no discipline. We are witnessing an organisation plagued by internal disagreements and mismanagement that is grappled by self-interest”.

Tensions have continued to escalate within the party following reports of internal power struggles, the arrest of several MK members of Parliament, and leadership disputes surrounding the party’s caucus. Chief Whip Colleen Makhubele is facing mounting calls for her removal, with analysts citing her for causing division and centralising power within the party. On the other hand, Ndhlela has continuously denied reports of his removal as the MP, despite leaked letters that suggest the opposite. He insists no official communication was brought forth to that effect and rather maintains that this could be a smart campaign made to discredit him and other members.

In a statement likely to further inflame tensions, Mathabe alleged that nepotism of individuals with close ties to the founder of the MK Party Jacob Zuma, such as girlfriends, grandchildren, nieces, and nephews are occupying parliamentary seats that were not earned through the formal electoral process. “ These are not the people the movement selected or submitted to the IEC. These are not the names South Africans voted for. The people in Parliament today do not reflect the official list we gave the Electoral Commission”, Mathabe said. He advised that such practices are not only unethical but could lead to electoral fraud.

The MK Party rose to prominence in December 2023 under Jacob Zuma, attracting thousands of supporters in South Africa and promising to return the ideals of radical transformation, anti-corruption governance, and revolutionary integrity. However, less than a year into its role in Parliament, the party is already facing public scrutiny of a legitimacy crisis. According to Mathabe, MK has abandoned its foundational promises and is rapidly losing its credibility on its own doing.

“ People joined MK because they believed in something different. But what we are seeing is the worst version of politics with power grabs, paranoia, and political thuggery”, said Mathabe. He added that without serious reflection and urgent reform, the MK Party risks disintegration under the burden of its conflicts.

Political critics are currently questioning the MK’s sustainability within its internal dysfunction. Dr Nomsa Mahlangu, a political analyst from the University of Johannesburg, says the MK’s problems emanate from its over-dependence on personality politics. “ This is a party centred around Zuma’s name, not a clear vision on policies or democratic structures. What we are seeing now is the inevitable fallout from that”.

As for Mathabe, his warning is clear, MK was meant to be different. But if it does not return to its founding values and correct course, it will fade into history as just another failed promise”.